I really don’t need to expound on how entertaining Star Trek is, because everyone else is, and they are not wrong or exaggerating.
One Major Flaw (its good enough that I need to be really picky): Red Matter - while a single drop carefully dispensed with a syringe easily collapses a massive planet, gallons of it only consumed a Romulan space ship and caused a lack-of-thrust issue for the Enterprise! – they should have let the Enterprise escape to warp speed only to then suffer deceleration as the well expanded. The crew would desperately calculate the effective-edge of the black hole, and have to do something very last second – a count down – to escape its pull.
It has been used in Star Trek in the past to turn into high gravity objects, to go where no man has gone before, achieve massive speed, and then use their power to steer clear of doom!
I can’t hold’er together Capt’n.
Scott, Warp 5 in 3 seconds or we’re all dead.
I would have been neat if they went beyond Newtonian physics for the escape of the gravity well of the story. I realize this simplicity is part of the appeal, but a little taste of relativity and subspace would have been a new twist (no magic solution please).
The Romulan space ship was magnificent.
BTW – in Next Generation tradition the mass of the Red Matter would have been identified as a massive risk, everyone worried. Oh no, how will they survive? But in the end, and magically, the RM would create its own portal into a further dimension and disappear. Sandwiches anyone?
Thank Vulcan they used the original Kirk Star Trek for inspiration!
TWO: OK, so I have another suggestion for the movie, an opportunity lost. Given our world of necessarily committing to something(s) and aspiring to goals, something that we all go through, and which Kirk lacked to start, there could have been a thread in the movie where Kirk is questioning his own participation in StarFleet. In the end, he sees, as others clearly did, how natural and essential his participation with StarFleet is for himself and as part of his true identity. Yes a space-opera coming of age theme; a contribution to the making of the man Kirk! As it stands the yahoo kid doesn’t exactly grow up, StarFleet just accepts his roughness.
PS.
There is a lot of conversation content in the new movie from Wrath of Khan – take a gander at the quotes – quite entertaining.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0084726/quote
Looking forward to the next one!